![Wriggling Free of Perfection [THE EEL]](https://jonathanrosenbaum.net/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/theeel.jpg)
![[Podcast] Making Brands Relevant: How to Connect Culture, Creativity & Commerce with Cyril Louis](https://justcreative.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/cyril-lewis-podcast-29.png)
Death Star Detail in ROGUE ONE Makes Alderaan’s Destruction in NEW HOPE Even More Devestating For Princess Liea
Star Wars fans are always rewatching, reanalyzing, and recontextualizing the films and shows in the franchise. Thanks to Andor and a fresh look at Rogue One, one specific connection has started to sting a little more, specifically a new perspective on Princess Leia’s reaction to Alderaan’s destruction in A New Hope.On Reddit, a fan recently pointed out something that many of us might not have considered, and now it’s hard to unsee. Leia wasn’t unfamiliar with what the Death Star could do when Tarkin ordered the obliteration of her home planet, but what she saw still shattered her.The post reads: "In A New Hope, when Leia is forced to watch Alderaan be destroyed, she reacts with horror and surprise (valid reaction).” It goes on:"But there’s a second part to this I never realized until I just watched Rogue One again. She was present at Scarif. She saw the effects of the Death Star there. “She was not present at Jedha, but I’m sure she heard of the aftermath. So in her mind, as Tarkin gives the order, she’s expecting a big explosion on the surface and a lot of people to die. “And then her entire planet just vaporizes in a second, right before her eyes. Completely subverting not just her expectations, but the Rebellion's."That’s the gut punch. Leia knew it was coming, but she just didn’t know how bad it was going to be.In Rogue One, Leia is nearby when Scarif is hit by the Death Star, watching the fallout from a distance just after the plans are transmitted aboard the Tantive IV. That moment, along with the wreckage at Jedha, gave the Rebellion a preview of the weapon’s destructive force. But Alderaan’s destruction wasn’t just a tactical display, it was personal. And the weapon wasn’t just killing people this time, it was wiping out Leia’s past, her culture, and her entire planet in an instant.One fan also noted the stark contrast in how the destruction is shown:"It's wild to go from the drama of Rogue One showing the Death Star looming over Jedha and Scarif, people reacting from the ground, detailed, up-close destruction of the planets' crust rending apart as the music swells… to Alderaan instantly turning into a stock footage explosion that the camera only lingers on for about four seconds with almost no fanfare."Sure, some of that difference is technical limitations. A New Hope was made in 1977 andRogue One in 2016, but the emotional difference is amplified when you watch in story order. In Rogue One, the destruction feels colossal and terrifying. By the time we get to Alderaan in A New Hope, the horror is quieter, but for Leia, now seen in a new light, it’s far more devastating.With Andor recently filling in more about the construction of the Death Star and the origins of the Rebellion, this small but interesting connection just adds another layer to Leia’s story.
Star Wars fans are always rewatching, reanalyzing, and recontextualizing the films and shows in the franchise. Thanks to Andor and a fresh look at Rogue One, one specific connection has started to sting a little more, specifically a new perspective on Princess Leia’s reaction to Alderaan’s destruction in A New Hope.
On Reddit, a fan recently pointed out something that many of us might not have considered, and now it’s hard to unsee. Leia wasn’t unfamiliar with what the Death Star could do when Tarkin ordered the obliteration of her home planet, but what she saw still shattered her.
The post reads: "In A New Hope, when Leia is forced to watch Alderaan be destroyed, she reacts with horror and surprise (valid reaction).” It goes on:
"But there’s a second part to this I never realized until I just watched Rogue One again. She was present at Scarif. She saw the effects of the Death Star there.
“She was not present at Jedha, but I’m sure she heard of the aftermath. So in her mind, as Tarkin gives the order, she’s expecting a big explosion on the surface and a lot of people to die.
“And then her entire planet just vaporizes in a second, right before her eyes. Completely subverting not just her expectations, but the Rebellion's."
That’s the gut punch. Leia knew it was coming, but she just didn’t know how bad it was going to be.
In Rogue One, Leia is nearby when Scarif is hit by the Death Star, watching the fallout from a distance just after the plans are transmitted aboard the Tantive IV.
That moment, along with the wreckage at Jedha, gave the Rebellion a preview of the weapon’s destructive force. But Alderaan’s destruction wasn’t just a tactical display, it was personal.
And the weapon wasn’t just killing people this time, it was wiping out Leia’s past, her culture, and her entire planet in an instant.
One fan also noted the stark contrast in how the destruction is shown:
"It's wild to go from the drama of Rogue One showing the Death Star looming over Jedha and Scarif, people reacting from the ground, detailed, up-close destruction of the planets' crust rending apart as the music swells… to Alderaan instantly turning into a stock footage explosion that the camera only lingers on for about four seconds with almost no fanfare."
Sure, some of that difference is technical limitations. A New Hope was made in 1977 andRogue One in 2016, but the emotional difference is amplified when you watch in story order.
In Rogue One, the destruction feels colossal and terrifying. By the time we get to Alderaan in A New Hope, the horror is quieter, but for Leia, now seen in a new light, it’s far more devastating.
With Andor recently filling in more about the construction of the Death Star and the origins of the Rebellion, this small but interesting connection just adds another layer to Leia’s story.
